| Year | Name | School |
| 2020 | Max Johnson | Louisiana State University |
| 2020 | Ben Noland | Northern State Univerity |
| 2019 | Andre Witt | Dodge City Community College |
| 2019 | Sam Shurtleff | University of Nebraska |
| 2019 | Miles Pettway | CSU Pueblo |
| 2019 | Dareon Goodrum | East Central Community College (MS) |
| 2018 | Ty Paschal | Central Methodist University |
| 2018 | Andrew Flemming | Taylor University |
| 2018 | Dylan Pettway | Texas Wesleyan |
| 2018 | CJ Brewer | Dodge City CC |
| 2018 | Blaize Williams | Minnesota West CC |
| 2017 | Abe Noland | Western Carolina University |
| 2017 | Roques Dowdy | Mars Hill University |
| 2017 | Gavin Adcock | Georgia Southern University |
| 2017 | Colin Worsham | LaGrange College |
| 2016 | Zeb Noland | Iowa State University |
| 2016 | Jaleel Laguins | University of Georgia |
| 2016 | Tyler Davis | Butler Community College |
| 2015 | Eli Cheely | Milsaps College |
| 2015 | Clark Nelson | US Coast Guard Academy |
| 2015 | Jed Woodward | Berry College |
| 2014 | Patrick McArdie | Valparaiso University |
| 2014 | Devin Orrell | Millikin University |
| 2013 | Nathan Adams | Maryville College |
| 2013 | Billy Seward | University of Georgia |
| 2012 | Connor White | Fork Union / Texas State University |
| 2012 | Logan Reach | Lenoir Rhyne |
| 2012 | Billy Seward | University of Georgia |
| 2009 | Nicholas Giancola | US Coast Guard Academy |
| 2008 | Blake Sailors | University of Georgia |
| 2008 | Zach Mettenberg | University of Georgia |
| 2008 | Ryan Ard | Birmingham Southern |
| 2008 | Ventrail Hunter | West Georgia University |
| 2007 | Scott Dalton | Virginia Tech |
| 2006 | Josh Sailors | University of Georgia |
| 2006 | Wade Woodall | LaGrange College |
| 2006 | Mykhal Briones | Union College |
| 2006 | Nathaniel Grider | West Virgina Tech |
| 2005 | Russ Callaway | Valdosta State |
| 2005 | Bo Stansell | University of Georgia |
| 2005 | Nic Ayoob | Furman University |
| 2005 | Andrew Johnson | University of Georgia |
| 2005 | Jonathan Rogers | Valdosta State |
| 2004 | Tyler Warden | Georgia Military College |
| 2004 | Justin Smith | LaGrange College |
| 2004 | Jordan Smith | Valdosta State University |
| 2004 | Josh Gibson | Shorter College |
| 2002 | Caleb Massengill | Presbyterian College |
| 2002 | Jesse Painter | Presbterian College |
| 2002 | Clay Callaway | Valdosta State University |
| 2002 | Bo Galvin | Georgia Southern University |
| 2002 | Randy Reed | Shorter College |
| 2001 | Tony Taylor | University of Georgia |
| 2001 | Brad Bell | Furman University |
| 2001 | Tristan Owusu-Yaw | Furman University |
| 2001 | Beau Braswell | Wheaton College |
| 2001 | Claiborne Green | Morehouse College |
| 2001 | Chris Reese | West Georgia University |
| 2001 | Bo Silva | West Georgia University |
| 2001 | TJ Stephens | University of Georgia |
| 2001 | Alphonso Dunston | Morehouse College |
| 2000 | Chad Kelley | Newberry College |
| 2000 | Tyson Browning | University of Georgia |
| 2000 | Clayton Matthews | James Madison University |
| 1999 | Willie Johnson | Georgia Southern University |
| 1999 | Jerry Willoughby | North Greenville College |
| 1999 | JT Cape | Duke University |
| 1999 | Jeremy Phillips | Georgia Tech |
| 1999 | Travis Pickering | North Greenville College |
| 1999 | Allen Harrison | James Madison University |
| 1998 | Josh Hepner | Appalachian State University |
| 1998 | Rick Morris | Appalachian State University |
| 1997 | Duane Vanderkooi | Georgia Southern University |
| 1997 | Josh Thornton | East Tennessee State University |
| 1994 | Nicholas Horton | Presbyterian College |
| 1994 | Rico Stephens | Mars Hill College |
| 1993 | Pat Brown | West Georgia University |
| 1992 | Clete Marshall | University of Georgia |
| 1987 | Daryl Hopkins | Georgia Southern University |
| 1987 | Eugene Hayes | Georgia Southern University |
| 1985 | Greg Reaves | West Georgia University |
| 1984 | Ken Burnette | Georgia Southern University |
| 1984 | Ben Bridges | Georgia Southwestern University |
| 1978 | Mitch Sims | University of Tennessee |
** Denotes played in the NFL
